The perceived contradiction between sustainability and returns proved, during our recent roundtable at APG, to be above all an invitation to look beneath the surface. With less mandatory ESG reporting, the risk of opacity increases, and it is precisely the role of non-executive directors to continue probing for evidence, scenarios, and underlying assumptions.
The 1.5 °C target remains an important reference point, even if it is no longer fully achievable in certain sectors. This makes it all the more important for non-executive directors to safeguard realistic transition pathways, scrutinize the costs of delay, and encourage bold choices on innovation and biodiversity. Governance plays a crucial role here: where governments leave gaps, courts intervene. The question then becomes whether engagement, voting, or divestment is the right route — including in dialogue with peers who hold different views.
Blikverruimer Arjen Kool deepened the discussion with reflections on the energy impact of AI, the balance between short- and long-term actions, and the importance of personal leadership. His call to action: “Who will I have a conversation with this week to put this issue higher on the agenda?”
Special thanks to Claudia Kruse and Lineke Sneller for their preparation and contributions. For further insight, we shared the new WEF report on investing in nature, ABP’s biodiversity policy and voting policy, and the IIGCC website, which illustrates how investors view climate and governance.